Discussion Questions for this book

After reading Esperanza Rising, use these questions to start a discussion about the book. Readers can share their thoughts with other kids around the country via the Book Bulletin Board.

You can also use any of these questions as a writing prompt.

Grade Level: 3-8

1. Why does the author open with a scene of Esperanza and her father lying down to hear the heartbeat of the earth? How does this shared experience seem to affect Esperanza’s relationship with her father?
   
   
2. Explain Mama’s reasons for leaving Mexico. Would you have been willing to make the same decision if you were in her situation? Why or why not?
   
   
3. Esperanza and Miguel take a train ride together as young children. Compare this train ride to the one they take when going to live in America.
   
   
4. What does Esperanza mean when she says to Miguel that there is a “deep river” that runs between them? Does this change in California? If so, describe how their relationship changes and give reasons for why this might happen.
   
   
5. Describe the cabin where Esperanza must live in America. How does this home compare to her home in Mexico? When Esperanza points out these differences, why does Mama become angry with her? Is Mama right to be angry with her? Why or why not?
   
   
6. Why does Esperanza dislike Marta when they first meet? What makes Esperanza change her mind about Marta?
   
   
7. After the dust storm, Mama is the only one of the workers in the cabin to become ill. Why is this so? How does her illness affect Esperanza? Why does Esperanza agree to cut the eyes out of the potatoes?
   
   
8. When Esperanza is told she cannot visit her mother for several weeks, she describes her life as going through “the motions of living.” Have you ever felt this way? If so, describe how. What does Esperanza do to increase the amount of joy in her life?
   
   
9. Why does Miguel drive out of his way to shop at the Japanese store? What does Alfonso mean when he tells Miguel that Mr. Yakota is “getting rich on other people’s bad manners”?
   
   
10. Compare the strikers’ camp to the camp in which Esperanza lives. How does seeing this camp and its inhabitants affect Esperanza?
    
    
11. Alfonso and Miguel keep telling Esperanza that if is she does good work the farmers will keep employing her. Do you believe that philosophy applies in today’s world? Why or why not?
    
    
12. What do you think of “voluntary deportation”? Is this a peaceful or violent way to handle the situation with the strikers? Did Esperanza do the right thing by helping Marta and risking the chance of being deported herself?
    
    
13. Papa’s words, “Wait a little while and the fruit will fall into your hands,” are said by Miguel in a heated argument with Esperanza. How does this idea relate to the titles of the chapters in this novel? How does this relate to the end of the novel when Esperanza is retelling all the events from California to Abuelita.
    
    
14. When Esperanza finds out Miguel has taken her money orders, she is devastated. Describe how she must feel when Alfonso comes to take her to the train station to pick Miguel up. Is she justified to feel this way? What was Miguel’s reason for taking the money? What do his actions mean?
    
    
15. The last section of the novel has Esperanza and Miguel listening to the heartbeat of the earth. What does this parallel to the first chapter mean?
    
    
16. The novel ends with Esperanza teaching Isabel how to crochet the zigzag stitch. How do the “mountains and valleys” compare to the plot of the novel?
    
    
17. Read the last sentence of the novel, and explain how it relates to the book's themes.

Some questions are adapted from Scholastic Authors and Books: A Discussion Guide to Esperanza Rising. View the reading guide free.